Easy High Protein Smoothie Recipes Without Protein Powder

High protein smoothies can be a game-changer—especially when sitting down to a meal feels impossible. Whether you have ADHD, anxiety, ARFID, are wrangling kids and their 10 extracurriculars, or just need quick nourishment, smoothies can help. In this post, you’ll learn how to make a high protein smoothie without protein powder using easy, budget-friendly ingredients—and you’ll get 6 delicious recipes to try right away.

I remind my clients all the time: when chewing feels like too much, drinking your nutrients is more than okay. And yes, they can be high protein and high fiber smoothies—no protein powder required.

*This post may contain affiliate links, meaning I earn a small commission (at no extra cost to you!) if you purchase through my links. Thanks for supporting my work!

How to Make a High Protein Smoothie (Without Protein Powder)

Creating a high protein smoothie doesn’t need to be complicated. Keeping it simple helps reduce overwhelm and cleanup.

Why high protein? I imagine you’re reading this because drinking nutrients on the go feels more appealing than sitting down to chew a meal. Protein is important for this because it slows down the digestion of carbs and keeps us feeling fuller, longer. Fats do too but more on that later.

Also, most times when a client tells me they’re drinking a smoothie for breakfast, it usually consists of only fruit. Which is super tasty and refreshing, don’t get me wrong.

But if your goal is to feel full and satisfied for longer than 30 minutes — adding in protein is a must.

Blender Recommendation

I love using a Nutribullet for individual smoothies—it minimizes dishes and ensures easy cleanup. Vitamix is also popular but can be quite pricey. Here are some great “dupes” for the Nutribullet and Vitamix.

• Hamilton Beach Portable Blender (for individual smoothies)
• Ninja Detect Power Blender Pro + Personal Single-Serve — (for individual AND multiple smoothies) ok if I was in the market for a blender, I’d get this one. I have a lot of Ninja appliances and love everyone of them.
• Magic Bullet (for individual smoothies)
• Black + Decker (classic, counter top blender)

Simple Formula for Easy Protein Shakes

Here’s an easy formula to follow for consistently delicious smoothies:

• Protein Base: Milk of choice (cow’s milk, soy milk), Greek yogurt, kefir, cottage cheese, premixed protein shake
• Fiber and Taste: Frozen fruit (berries, bananas, peaches)
• Fats: Peanut butter or other nut butters
• Fiber and Carbs: Oats (for extra creaminess and sustained energy)
• Bonus (Feeling adventurous?): Frozen vegetables for extra micronutrients

The Secret Ingredient Most Smoothie Recipes Miss

One of the biggest mistakes I see in smoothie recipes? They skip the fat.

But fat is essential—especially when you’re using produce that contain fat-soluable vitamins. Fat-soluble vitamins are vitamins A, D, E, and K, which means your body needs dietary fat to actually absorb them.

Your high protein smoothie needs dietary fats—like nut butter, avocado, coconut milk, or full-fat dairy—not just for nutrient absorption, but to help keep you full and satisfied.

Avoiding dietary fats can lead to restriction, which often results in overeating and an unhealthy relationship with food.

Pro-tip: skip the fat free dressing the next time you’re having a salad and grab the full-fat flavorful dressing instead. If that feels scary due to body image struggles, you might want to read this post.

How to Add Protein to Smoothies Without Protein Powder

No protein powder? No problem. Many of them are expensive, and honestly, most just don’t taste great or have a great texture.

If you’re wondering how to add protein to smoothies naturally, here are my go-to whole-food options:

• Cow’s Milk: Classic protein-rich base.
• Soy Milk: A good plant-based alternative to cow’s milk—comparable nutrient-wise.
• Greek Yogurt: Creamy texture and high protein.
• Premade Protein Shake: Premiere Protein, Fairlife Core Power, Orgain.
• Protein Powder: Sorry, no recommendations here—my tastebuds haven’t recovered from my dieting years, and I personally don’t enjoy the taste of protein powder. But it’s an option if you like it!
• Kefir: Adds beneficial probiotics for gut health.
• Cottage Cheese: Creamy, subtle flavor, packed with protein.

Vegetables to Put in Smoothies

Looking for the best vegetables to put in smoothies? Frozen options provide fiber and other beneficial nutrients—and most of them are virtually tasteless. They don’t go bad quickly like fresh and are great if you have a budget to stick to.

• Cauliflower: No taste, won’t change color, makes smoothies thick and creamy—perfect for toppings. Contains vitamins B6 and C.
• Zucchini: Mild taste, minimal color change. Rich in vitamins B6 and C.
• Spinach: Will definitely change the smoothie color, which can be fun! Generally mild taste. Contains iron, folate, magnesium, potassium, vitamins K, A, and C.
• Sweet Potatoes: Adds sweetness, thickens smoothies. Provides vitamins A, C, manganese, and beta carotene.

Not sure where to start? Try tossing in just a handful of frozen cauliflower or zucchini—you won’t even taste it! If you’re looking for more guidance around how to eat veggies if you don’t like them — check out this post.

Easy Protein Smoothie Recipes

I went ahead and did the searching for you! These easy protein smoothie recipes don’t require protein powder and use simple, nourishing ingredients you likely already have on hand.

• Blueberry Smoothie with Almond Butter (vegetarian-friendly, includes flavor variations)
• Kid-Friendly PB&J Smoothie (kid-approved, easy step-by-step pictures to make preparation stress-free and simple, especially helpful for visual learners or busy families to follow)
• Blueberry Coconut Smoothie with Banana and Oats (from Cara—love everything she posts!)
• Chocolate Peanut Butter Smoothie with Banana and Dates (another delicious chocolate option from Cara)
• Yogurt Peanut Butter Cup Smoothie (Jackie is an RD specializing in nutrition counseling for neurodivergent and disabled clients; her website is a wealth of information)
• Strawberry Cottage Cheese Smoothie (awesome variations and substitutions—I’ve never tried cottage cheese in a smoothie before, but it sounds awesome!)

Toppings For Smoothie Bowls

If you aren’t on the go and are feeling fancy, toppings can be a fun addition. Try these:

• Granola for crunch
• Drizzled nut butter
• Seeds or nuts, flax seeds, chia seeds
• Sliced fruit

Smoothies are a convenient and tasty way to ensure you’re nourished, especially when life feels busy or complicated. Try these recipes, experiment with your favorite ingredients, and enjoy the ease of drinking your nutrients!

Got a favorite smoothie combo or tip I missed? I’d love to hear it—drop a comment or check out more non-diet tips on my blog!

For more no-fuss, nutrition support—sign up for my free newsletter.